In 2007 Sam James was a young barista at another coffee shop when he served an espresso to Scott Rao, who handed it back and asked for his money back. Rao then walked him through everything wrong with the shot. The lesson James took from it was consistency: water filtration, machine, pressure profile and above all the roast have to be right every time before anyone starts experimenting. A year later he won Barista of the Year, judged by James Hoffmann, and in 2009 he opened his first coffee bar, in Little Italy.

“Coffee should be a break, not an adventure,” is his line, and the roasting follows it. Sam James roasts one kind of coffee: sweet, chocolatey, naturally developed medium roasts that are forgiving to brew on a high-end espresso machine or a basic drip machine. The roaster is a hand-built, cast-iron, direct-flame drum machine from Portugal, fully preheated before every batch, and modern roast-tracking software watches each batch and flags any variation before the team tastes it. The green coffee is this year’s crop, bought through the importer Cafe Imports, and every coffee is bought above Fairtrade minimum prices, without paying to license the Fairtrade logo. Orders are roasted and shipped in the same week.

Butter Knife espresso is behind every drink in the shops; the roaster tastes peanut butter, berry jam and toffee in it. There are four Sam James Coffee Bars, in Little Italy, Parkdale, Ossington and the underground PATH network downtown. The menu is kept short so every drink gets proper attention: espresso drinks start with Butter Knife, shots are pulled on La Marzocco machines, and drip coffee is brewed fresh through the day. Bags are on the shelf to take home.

Over the years the business started roasting for other Toronto coffee shops, and more than 20 partner cafés now pour its coffee.

Coffee on the shelf

Photograph: Sam James Coffee Bar