Cow’s milk is made for calves, and you were weaned a long time ago. We make the case against dairy in our Vegan x specialty coffee: the worldwide café guide.

We use oat milk in a flat white, and we’ve found that some cartons work much better in coffee than others.

A hand pours oat drink from a cut-glass jug into a glass of iced coffee beside a grey Oatly Barista Edition carton on a pink tablecloth set with glassware.

Why the carton should say barista

Plain oat drink and barista oat drink aren’t the same product. Alpro’s barista carton, for example, adds pea protein and an acidity regulator that its ordinary oat drink doesn’t have1.

The acidity regulator is there because coffee is acidic. Without it, the drink can split into flecks when it hits the cup, which Oatly calls feathering2.

Barista cartons also have added oil. Oatly and Alpro both have 3 g of fat per 100 ml, and Oatly credits its Barista Edition’s “rich and neutral taste” to oats and unsaturated fat3.

Our three favourite oat milks

Per 100 ml Oatly Barista Edition3 Alpro Barista Oat1 Minor Figures Barista Oat4
Oats 10% 10% 11%
Fat 3.0 g 3.0 g 2.2 g
Sugars 3.4 g 3.3 g 2.5 g
Protein 1.1 g 0.8 g 0.4 g
Oil Rapeseed Sunflower Rapeseed

Oatly Barista Edition: our overall pick

A grey one-litre carton of Oatly Barista Edition oat drink seen from the front right, printed with a steaming coffee cup.

Oatly Barista Edition is our overall pick because it has the best balance of taste and creaminess. It’s made from water, 10% oats and rapeseed oil, with dipotassium phosphate as the acidity regulator, and Oatly promises “no separating in the coffee”3.

In a blind test that Which? ran in March 2026, the four professional coffee tasters liked Oatly’s biscuit and malt flavour, although some of them found the oat taste too strong and the finish chalky5.

Alpro Barista Oat: the alternative

The front of a one-litre Alpro Barista Oat carton in yellow and white, showing a cup of coffee with latte art seen from above.

Alpro Barista Oat has the same amount of fat as Oatly but uses sunflower oil in place of rapeseed, with a little pea protein1. Alpro describes its oat taste as mild1, and choosing between the two is a matter of taste.

Alpro’s flavoured barista drinks, Caramel and Cinnamon Roll, are a different recipe with 4.7% oats, soya and added sugar1, so make sure you pick up the plain carton.

Minor Figures Barista Oat: our pick for taste

A white one-litre Minor Figures Barista Oat carton with a teal line drawing of a figure in sunglasses wearing a duck-shaped swim ring and holding a cup.

Minor Figures is the one we like best for taste, and it’s the least sweet of the three at 2.5 g of sugars per 100 ml4. It’s less creamy than the other two because it has less fat, 2.2 g per 100 ml against 3 g4.

Two more oat milks worth trying

A hand pours oat drink from a small green jug into a glass mug of black coffee, with a bowl of coffee beans behind.

Califia Farms Oat Barista Blend won the Which? blind test of three barista oat milks, ahead of Alpro and Oatly. The tasters praised its silky look, its fuller body and a flavour that was “not too oaty”5. Its recipe is close to Oatly’s, with 10% oats, rapeseed oil and the same acidity regulator6.

Oat drink is poured from a steel jug into a glass of iced coffee on a wooden table, with a YoSoy Barista Avena carton and coffee beans behind.

YoSoy Barista Avena is the local option if you live in Spain. It’s made in Viladrau, a village in the Montseny7, from only four ingredients: water, 12% oats, oil and sea salt. It contains no acidity regulator and no stabilisers8.

Organic barista oat milk

A one-litre Oatly Barista Organic oat drink carton, grey on top and brown kraft below, printed with a steaming coffee cup.

The organic versions of Oatly and Minor Figures leave out the phosphate and use potassium carbonate instead910. Oatly says its Barista Organic “works best in a dark roast blend”9.

Why oat milk tastes sweet

None of the plain barista cartons has added sugar. The sweetness comes from production, when enzymes break the oat starch down into maltose, which is a sugar2, and that’s the 2.5 to 3.4 g per 100 ml on the labels.

How hot to steam oat milk

Plant milks are steamed a little cooler than dairy. Alexander Ntatsos, a two-time Swedish latte art champion, advises staying under 55°C and adding the air early11.

Why the carton says oat drink

In the European Union, the word milk is reserved by law for milk from animals, which is why cartons say oat drink. The Court of Justice confirmed the rule in 2017 in a case against a company called TofuTown12. Britain kept the rule after leaving the EU. Oatly registered the trade mark “Post Milk Generation” there, and the Supreme Court ruled against it in February 20261314.

We call it oat milk anyway, and if the word offends you, we hope you’re equally offended by hot dogs, peanut butter and shaving cream.

Oat milk and cow’s milk compared

Oat milk has a much smaller footprint than cow’s milk. In Our World in Data’s figures, a litre of it produces less than a third of the emissions and needs a fraction of the land and fresh water15.

Per litre Cow’s milk Oat milk
Greenhouse gases 3.15 kg CO₂e 0.90 kg CO₂e
Land 8.95 m² 0.76 m²
Fresh water 628 litres 48 litres

References

  1. Alpro, Barista Oat
  2. Oatly, health questions and answers for professionals
  3. Oatly, Oat Drink Barista Edition
  4. Morrisons, Minor Figures Barista Oat
  5. Which?, best barista-style oat milks for coffee
  6. Califia Farms, Oat Barista Blend
  7. Liquats Vegetals, about us
  8. YoSoy, Barista Avena
  9. Oatly, Oat Drink Barista Edition Organic
  10. Morrisons, Minor Figures Barista Organic Oat
  11. Perfect Daily Grind, which milks are best for latte art?
  12. Court of Justice of the European Union, press release 63/17, TofuTown
  13. UK Supreme Court, Dairy UK Ltd v Oatly AB
  14. Mishcon de Reya, Supreme Court rules Post Milk Generation trade mark invalid for plant-based products
  15. Our World in Data, dairy vs plant-based milk: what are the environmental impacts?

Photo credits