Cuppers Choice began with Jasper and Harley, who worked together for a coffee roaster in Nottingham, Harley as a director and Jasper in Sheffield. In February 2020 the roaster Steve Penk let them use his Loring S15, and with a third partner who ran a coffee shop with a back room they started roasting. Their first manifesto, written in a pub, was to buy incredible green coffee, sell it cheaply, never profit from equipment, avoid supply contracts and pay producers the best prices around. The name and the ornate, heritage look came next, with logos and labels by the Norwich sign writer Kieran Harper.

The first big purchase was a container of Rwandan coffee financed on credit through Algrano, and Emmanuel Rusatira in Rwanda became its first direct trade partner. A second direct relationship followed with Diego Robelo of Aquiares Estate in Costa Rica, who supplies the house espresso. Cuppers also pre-finances lots: it paid for its Ermera coffee from Timor-Leste about a year before it shipped, so that Raw Material could buy parchment from smallholders and build more washing stations. It once gave half the turnover of a coffee to Islamic Relief for Palestine, raising about three thousand pounds.

In 2025 the company leased an old unit in Sheffield and built its own roastery, ending three roast days a week in Chesterfield, and installed two IRM roasters of 30 and 3 kilos. Every coffee is cupped by the team before it passes quality control, and the ones that pass carry a diamond seal. Retail tubs gave way to simpler packaging, on the view that packaging money should go to the green coffee. The team also launched a separate café brand serving lattes, now with three sites, two in the Manchester area and one in Sheffield.

Partner cafés

Coffee on the shelf

Photograph: Cuppers Choice